Choicest Games 2012 Game of the Year
- Winner: Mass Effect 3
- Runner-Up: XCOM: Enemy Unknown
Choicest Games 2011 Game of the Year
- Winner: Portal 2
- Runner-Up: Gray Matter
Choicest Games 2010 Game of the Year
- Winner: Mass Effect 2
- Runner-Up: Starcraft 2
Choicest Games 2009 Game of the Year
- Winner: Monkey Island: Special Edition
- Runner-Up: Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2
- Runner-Up: Fallout 3
Choicest Games 2008 Game of the Year
- Winner: Left 4 Dead
- Runner-Up: Mass Effect